David Guetta and the Fate of House Music

Guetta's Recent Success Arouses Many Questions for Electronia

4 Comments
Join the Conversation
David Guetta's New Catchphrase - Aptly Titled... - killingbeats.com
David Guetta's New Catchphrase - Aptly Titled... - killingbeats.com
Guetta has recently skyrocketed to the top of the charts, consistently ranking within the top 5 DJ's. It is time to consider the accuracy of this. Is Guetta deserving?

It hardly seems as though an introduction to David Guetta is necessary these days, his songs topping charts and radio broadcasts alike. The French DJ is responsible for a multitude of "house" tracks in recent years, with his most recent album titled "One Love".

Though relatively new to the US scene, Guetta has exerted some influence in music in Europe for years. His recent collaborations with popular American hip-hop/pop singers such as Akon, Kelly Rowland, and Kid Cudi have lended to this mass appeal, as has his widepsread promoting around the globe. He was rated third in the poll of top 100 DJ's of 2009, and it is clear that he is still on the rise. The question that begs to be answered, is why!?!?

What is the secret behind Guettas rise to fame? Surely it cant be the songs themselves. The cheesy uninspired tracks seem to be good for one thing only; packing a dance floor. The downside is that once the audience sobers up and realizes the audible noise they've been subjected to, the crowd is certain to leave in waves.

Deconstructing David Guetta

Guetta's music seems to follow the same simple formula for each song. The beginning provides an unoriginal, yet catchy, melody synced with an often high pitched chorus (consisting of one short phrase sung over and over. and over. and over...) that is introduced shortly after. The two are then repeated with little variation throughout the length of the track. After the first minute or two the initial bass drops in, a loud, upbeat, booming sort, that still contains the unchanging nature of the earlier parts. The song remains in a constant loop from then on, the only real distinction being the bass which drops in and out periodically (though at equally predictable intervals).

Perhaps this is the reason why nearly all of his songs require that the vocals be the focal point, in order to detract from the boring droning of the beats themselves. Unfortunately it is too late to salvage. A key facet of Guetta's songs appears to be a steady repetition of exact same sounds for minutes on end, to the point where one is forced to either turn it off or change the track just to hear some variety.

Tracks from his earlier albums had a certain striking simplicity to them, with a chorus that sticks in one's head for hours, perhaps the very reason why some found him appealing. "Just a Little More Love" for example, though hardly a masterpiece of art and craftsmanship, was a formidable song to party to. Ten years ago. After hearing his next fifty releases as essentially the same track, any nostalgia for Guetta's early songs has long since died. And then beaten unmercifully on a regular basis to ensure that no life may ever be breathed into them again.

The Key to Guetta's Success

Given the nature of Guetta's sound one would expect him to be an astute performer who could draw any crowd. A recent show at a large rave in Los Angeles actually demonstrated hordes of people running to the stage a few short songs after Guetta stepped on. Unfortunately for Guetta, it was the stage on the other side of the venue. Not only did Guetta fail to achieve anything noteworthy in his liveset, he was clearly unable to gauge the audience even a little, taking the stage after progressive house DJ, John Digweed, and sending such a flurry of people away from his set that there was a line just to leave the area. Yet somehow scenes like this has done little to dissuade his growing arrogance, as the flood of merchandise and one-hit songs continues.

Guetta's success seems more dependent on pumping out goods and pleasing the masses than pursuing any real innovation or talent. It seems that he no longer cares what his name is attached to, so long as he turns a profit. This mass-production approach towards music ensures that the only real distinction for Guetta is which singer of the month will appear dancing alongside him in his videos.

The Aftermath

Perhaps the most disheartening feature of Guetta's impact on modern music is the ease with which it has been assimilated. Within a genre that was once defined by its creativity and progressive nature, the current trend seems to be stagnating, or worse, regressing. Many of the highest rated DJ's are now those who follow this pattern, forsaking any true innovation and integrity for the commercial. Such a mainstream ideology has already overtaken many acclaimed DJ's, the most notable of which includes once legendary trance figure DJ Tiesto.

The expansive nature of the global scene breathes a sign of life back into Electronica, with names like Gareth Emery, Sasha, and Markus Schulz spreading it's true essence. Unfortunately, however, the genre itself is gradually becoming associated with the pretentiousness of DJ's out to commercialize their sound for a soon to be fading fame. It has become clear that the quickest way to make a name is not through innovation and dedicated fanbases, but instead by way of a cheesy, overproduced track with a featured Top40 artist. Some might say this trend was inevitable, but one can only hope that in the years to come House music will not remember David Guetta.

Jamil Karim at the Blue Mosque in Istanbul, Turkey, Jamil Karim

Jamil Karim - Jamil Karim is a California local of Indian descent who holds a BA in Philosophy and a prolonged interest in writing and journalism.Among ...

rss
Advertisement
Leave a comment

NOTE: Because you are not a Suite101 member, your comment will be moderated before it is viewable.
Submit
What is 8+4?

Comments

Dec 26, 2010 4:02 PM
Guest :
Honestly, i understand where your coming from.... but from my personal experience of being addicted to cheesy pop/rock songs and then now becoming in love with true trance tracks, i have to say David Guetta was once comparable to other high performance DJ's... but do you see any other DJ's rising in the US like David Guetta? No, its because he sold himself out and knew that working alongside clowns like Akon and Michelle whatever would make him famous in the US dance clubs. You have to consider that if you actually tried listening to some true trance songs, you would see that the dance scene is not over. People left Guetta's stage because some of them are insulted by his music, he's a sellout. But dance and electronic music will always be repetitive and for the most part sound similar to alot of songs because alot of sound effects that are repetitive are what get people into a TRANCE LIKE STATE. David Guetta doesnt really do this, other than to ridiculous US teenagers and young adults with no minds in the US clubs.
Let me guide you towards some true trance tracks, where vocals are not what make a track, its the whole quality of sound itself, and thats how i lost myself with trance i cant even bother to listen to crap on the radio anymore.
Ecstasy - ATB
Walk With Me - Tritonal
Not the Same - Markus Schulz
About You - Moonbeam
Imprisoned - Shogun
Hiding to Nothing - Beat Service
May 29, 2011 7:38 AM
Guest :
I'm not much of a House/Electro/Trance music listener, so I might not be an expert in saying what’s good and what’s not. But, in my opinion, there has never been a real good song in this style of music – ever. Don’t get me wrong, I’m talking about a good song, not a successful song.
A good song is a mix of inspired lyrics (hopefully with insightful thinking) with a great instrumental work and melodies that you can keep repeating day after day without boring yourself out.
But in my experience of House/Techno/Electro/Trance/Dance or whatever it is called now, I’ve never found such things. Yet it does not prevent me from liking some songs and this is simply because those songs have a purpose : making you want to move you’re body like – let’s face it – some strange ape on a dancefloor. And that’s all there is to know about it : simple music for simple purpose (I might here want to risk an awful comparison with X-Movies : they also serve a purpose so don’t bother trying to find an interesting scenario or catching dialogues…)

This must explain why Guetta takes credit for his songs that you describe as “pleasing the masses” : they are simple enough, great melodies, nice beat and no question because nobody want’s to go on a dancefloor to ponder philosophical lyrics or to try to figure out the musical complexity between the beats.

Again, this is only my humble opinion as profane so don’t be offended. I’m just one of them “masses” pleased by some of Guetta’s work.
Jul 12, 2011 6:58 AM
Guest :
God bless David will disappear and be remember as the cheesiest person after selling our scene !!! with the most corny songs ! and brain washed the kids that could be much more educated and have a different perspective of what is a REAL musician and playing as a dj , its over! everybody thinks he have to follow the steps from David , bc is the only thing that works , ... the truth is that for us is very difficult to hear this bullshit and don't be depressed , how can people like this terrible steeled exactly the same beat and some cheesy vocals that repeat 30x over and over , at least he is coping ooops! producing his own songs now , once Joaquim and Tocadisco cant see his face anymore , maybe thats why Afrojack is the new one on the use , at least is what looks like ;-) , nice to hear from some intelligent people in the other side!!!!
Jul 12, 2011 7:00 AM
Guest :
Btw , Markus Schulz don't even produce his own music , he have someone that do everything for him . just for info ;-)
4 Comments
Advertisement
Advertisement